Tuesday, April 15, 2008

Reproductive Justice

As some of us have already posted on the blog, I too though today's lecture was really great. The guest speakers Cara Page and Mia Mingus presented a lot of information that I had not been familiar with. However new this information was to me, I really understand and can see its role in our society today. I had never thought of how marginalized groups could be blamed for environmental degradation. However, after seeing the various clips portrayed by media, I really could understand how much influence these images can have. Moreover, what I find to be sad is that many people do not interpret such clips to be negative; they read the articles and flip through the various photos that in essence, blame, colored groups for these environmental problems without realizing how untruthful this portrayal is.



Another aspect of today's lecture that I had never really given though to was why women of color are fighting to have children. Although I was aware of the lack of services that are offered in areas in which there are a high number of minority women, I had never thought of why this was the case. The same goes for the schooling and other conditions that make it difficult to raise a child in such areas. The fact that these women do not have the choice that Caucasian women may have is unjust. It is not fair to restrict some groups of people from services that are offered to others for no apparent reason. Aren't we all supposed to be created equal? Is that not one of the founding ideas of the United States?

story of stuff and reproductive justice

Today's class discussion about power and control reminded me of the Story of Stuff video we all watched last week in addition to a course that I took my freshman year. Of what I took from today, one of the biggest points seemed to be that the marginalized or "other" in society do not in fact create the environment that they are subjected to. They are not stuck there because they haven't taken the initiative to rise above or because they created the situation for themselves. Rather, often their situation is a result of what the government, corporations, or those above them have enforced upon them. This is an issue that is presented broadly in the Story of Stuff video, and one that I studied a specific example of in my "Amazonian Rain Forest in Brazil" seminar that I took freshman year.
Like Annie Leonard describes in the video, people with power are destroying the environments of people in poorer countries. With this displacement they are forcing them to work in factories that pollute the world even more. This very thing is happening in the Amazon rain forest in Brazil. Corporations and wealthy upper class people are taking over the land of indigenous farmers and exploiting its resources. This wrecks the entire system of life of the indigenous people. The land that they work on and get food from is being taken over and they are being displaced from their homes into cities and slums. With none of their original farms and no access to traditional hunting and gathering, these people are forced to work for money. And from there, their only work opportunity, due to poverty and poor transportation, is to work for other corrupt corporations and factories. These factories only pollute the world and exploit its resources more. It is a seemingly hopeless situation.
Side note - this situation ties into modern slavery again. There are actual cases in which families will sell their children into slavery in order to have money to survive. Sometimes they will send them away to what they think are apprentice jobs or waitressing jobs, hoping they will send money home, and really, they are sending their kids to brothels and human trafficking chains.
Annie Leonard provides astounding statistics for this problem. One third of the planet's natural resources have been used in the past three decades. And globally, 200,000 people a day are being displaced and going to work in factories. Whole communities are being wasted. She even quotes that two thousand trees in the Amazon are being chopped down every minute. This misuse of resources and displacement of indigenous people is wrecking havoc on Brazil. And truly, as seen here, their situation is not the result of their own mishaps, rather it is all the result of powerful systems controlling their freedom.
Finally, it is important that we do not automatically label corporation's treatment of land as bad, and indigenous agriculture as good. The slash and burn agriculture of indigenous groups in the Amazon can be really bad for the soil. It strips the soil of its nutrients and isn't particularly sustainable in large amounts. Areas such as this are in need of a totally new and different system.

Poverty fuels medical crisis

In nowadays, poverty is taking bigger and bigger lenghts. It can be defined as one of the most important problems the world faces like Global Warming,cancer among the population,women's experimentation, and etc. We have to realize this "disease" in our society is a fact and we are the people who have to look around ourselves and try to give our best in order to overwhelm the problem!I think that everyone should be concerned about the lives other people lead and give them our assistance.

When I read the article "Poverty fuels medical crisis", I was shocked to find that there are so many people around the world who live in suffer. The examples which are given in it represent different cases of people's diseases and their helpless situation. The crisis in which Edna Saylor lives indicates the life of the old people and their insecurity. The data shows that this woman gets less than $8,500 a year which is intolerable toward her especially if she survives by her own. Edna Saylor has also some health problems with her heart, she has high blood pressure and poor circulation. Every intelligent person can conclude that this woman does not have enough funds to cover her medical expenses and live the life which people deserve. It is sad that a country like America which is really developed in medicine cannot secure, for example, the lives of its mothers and fathers.

I was also disappointed of the movie we watched in class about this man who lost two of his fingers. Obviously he did not have health insurance which was an obstacle for him, because he did not have enough money to pay for the surgery. I cannot understand how this country can make its citizens feel dependent with their health insurances. Don't you think that doctors should be more worried about their patients' health than their insurances? I think that doctors should give their best to save persons' lives and to think about their own goods after that.

La operacion

The movie called "La operacion" by Ana Maria Garcia which we watched in class made me think about the life which people in Puerto Rico had. During the movie I was trying to answer so many of my questions, for example: How did these women feel after the sterilization?; What did they think about this "medical method"?; Was it a Government exploitation?, etc.

This movie is a very good representation of women's exploitation in Puerto Rico. They were forced to be a part of a medical experimentation which was compulsory for all of them. The sterilization which almost every woman experienced was violation of their own rights. I cannot really understand how people can be manipulated like that and also be treated not as equal. For me, the worse part of the whole sterilization process was the lack of information which these Puerto Rican women had. I became a witness of a terrible attitude which doctors exercised among their patients.

One of the interesting questions for me was: "Why sterilization took place in Puerto Rico"? I think that this medical method was introduced there , because the majority of people were not educated and we all know that if people do not have the needed knowledge, they will have less doubts about sterilization like these women had. For me, the Government had the main responsibility of using sterilization among these poor people. It was trying to minimize the number of uneducated people and also to solve the problem with world's over-population. Even though, I do not agree with its brutal politic of sterilization, because the pain which these weak people suffered cannot be redempted. I know that over-population is one of the biggest and most complicated problems nowadays, but the method which the Government choose to overwhelm it has to be changed, because every human being deserves the right to live in peace.

Lesbian Bodies

I was really interested by Barbara Creed's article "Lesbian Bodies: Tribades, Tomboys, and Tarts". The author touched the idea of sexuality which can exist between women. In the past, lesbians were defined as "different" than other people and they were treated as breakers of the established social order. The Government considered, that lesbians can lead society to collapse, but through the years it decided to change its attitude toward these women.

Nowadays, the stance which mankind has toward lesbians is different, for example, such women can be married. Even though there are still some communities in the world which are more conservative and words like "lesbian" and "gay" are not appropriate for their cultures. I think that Barbara Creed tried to explain to the audience that even lesbians should be considered as "normal" human beings who deserve to exercise their sexual orientations. I think that these women should be accepted as the way they are and society should try to understand their emotions and preferences.

I have a friend who is a lesbian and she is a very kind and nice person. The relationship between her girlfriend and her is very strong and both of them enjoy it. I cannot really understand their feelings and experience, but I am pretty sure that they are one of the best couples I have ever seen. They both come from extremely pious families which is a problem for them to consume their love. This is a brief example of how religion stays between people's feelings. I am a pious person too, but as Shakespeare said:"Love is blind", I think that everyone should spend his or her life with the person they love in spite of all negative stance around them.

Thoughts on Today's Lecture--Reproductive Justice

I can't stop thinking about today's guest speakers and what they had to say about reproductive rights, population control, and eugenics. I have never heard of some of the ideas they discussed, and I think it's important to know about it...I'm glad I do now! The idea raised in class about blaming fertility as the root cause of social conditions and environment degradation was the most stunning to me. As someone else mentioned in class (I think it was Rosie), I also have never thought about the relations between population control, reproductive rights, and the environment. The best example was given through their media/visual presentation picture about what family planning can do to our environment. Many of us had different interpretations, which for me tells us what a complex and difficult issue this is. Looking at it from all of the angles we discussed in class, it seems like there are two main issues: either people aren't given their "reproductive right" and allowed to have a family due to discriminatory factors that come through politically and socially OR the questioning of who should and should not be reproduced based on the same political and social factors of discrimination. Both of these issues seem legitimate, but what is the other side arguing? What is keeping us from eliminating these issues? It stems directly from the same things we've been talking about in class about prejudices of race, class, gender, and sexual orientation. How is it that we're already able to label someone before they have even entered into this world?

Sunday, April 13, 2008

A Burst of Light: Living with Breast Cancer

In nowadays, the percentage of women who have or had breast cancer is too high. This is the second common type of cancer after lung cancer. From the data that we have during 2005 breast cancer caused 502,000 deaths world wide. While reading the articles about Lourde, I was surprised by the faith of this woman. She had the incredible ability to overwhelm her own tragedy. I am pretty sure that it was not an easy process for her, but nevertheless she succeed to preserve herself and be ready to fight for her survival.

Women's role in our society was and continues to be the role of the mother and the housewife. Most of the women were defined as sexual objects and only their appearance was valued. I think that this concept of admiring women only for their good looks continues through the centuries. Today, if a woman does not fall short of society's expectations, she will be ignored and outcasted from it. For example, the case of Lourde was the same and when she decided not to have a live biopsy she did not receive an understanding from her own doctor. This is really sad, because doctors should be the people who have to try comprehend their patients and give them confidence in order to endure their sickness. From this point of view we can conclude what will be society's opinion about the victims of breast cancer and their "horrible" consequences for it. Even all negativism which this woman went trough, she overcame her disease and society's views and continue to be loyal to her believes. I admire Lourde's strong spirit and the motivation which she had.